John Idzik: The Man With A Blueprint

When John Idzik was hired as the New York Jets general manager, local beat writers and national analysts painted him in a dull fashion. Seattle’s “cap guy” was everyone’s favorite description, which completely neglected his vast resume as a former VP of football administration. He was Seattle’s representative at league meetings, oversaw player negotiations and transactions, along with day to day football operations, all for a franchise that has nearly perfected the “rebuilding” phase.

With hopes he could develop a plan to elevate the Jets back into the AFC contender they once were, Woody Johnson hired the “cap guy.” What many have failed to recognize is that the Jets have brought in an architect who is ready to execute his blueprint.


Cut the “dead weight”; keep the cap flexible:

As the Jets searched for a new GM throughout the offseason, they were known to be in one of the worst salary cap situations in the entire NFL. Mike Tannenbaum had left the roster littered with terrible contracts. The Jets had made the classic mistake of having single digit players eating up a large majority of the cap, leaving no space for depth.

John Idzik came in and immediately went to work. Sione Pouha, Eric Smith, and Tim Tebow were no-brainer eliminations. After trading Darrelle Revis and the potential (looming) cuts of Mark Sanchez, Santonio Holmes, and Antonio Cromartie, the Jets will have nearly $50 million in cap space to work with in the 2014 offseason.

While many Jets fans are excited for the potential future cap space to sign top tier free agents, Idzik will most likely not hand out bloated contracts for stars. Muhammad Wilkerson has established himself as a superstar and will receive a well deserved contract extension. With a well established nucleus in place and about twelve draft picks (I will touch on this in detail) , Idzik will most likely use what I call the “Boston Red Sox” approach in free agency.

For those not familiar with the 2013 World Series Champion Red Sox, they signed a couple of middle tier free agents to reasonable contracts in the offseason, adding to an already well established nucleus. Plugging in these holes and developing a well rounded roster helped the Red Sox win a championship, while also not being handicapped in the upcoming seasons by absurd contracts. Idzik will not be afraid to spend big dollars on homegrown talent such as Wilkerson, but will not pay a receiver 10-12 million dollars per year much like Miami did with Mike Wallace this offseason.

Stockpile draft picks; consistently add young talent:

The best analogy I’ve seen describing the NFL draft is that it can be compared to the lottery. Even “safe picks” are no longer a sure thing. How do you better your chances when playing the lottery? It is quite simple actually: stockpile draft selections.

During the trade deadline fans were clamoring for Idzik to bring in a wide receiver to aid Geno Smith. While players like Josh Gordon were available, the Browns were demanding a second round pick AND a player in return. While Gordon is talented, he is one violation away from a year long NFL suspension. Idzik does not part ways with his draft selections, especially high selections for a player filled with character concerns.

Back to the Jets draft picks, they could potentially have twelve draft choices come May 2014. They have all seven of their original picks, a third round pick from the Buccaneers for Darrelle Revis (becomes a fourth round pick if he is cut – highly unlikely), and four potential compensatory picks.

As it stands Yeremiah Bell and Matt Slauson will most likely qualify as seventh round selections. Mike DeVito is highly likely to qualify as a fifth round pick, while LaRon Landry could qualify as a fourth rounder depending on how many more games he plays. Shonn Greene is also a potential qualifier as a 6th round pick, but much like Landry, he has missed a few games. A team can ultimately be rewarded up to four compensatory draft selections.

With twelve selections in the draft and six of them possibly being in the first four rounds, the Jets have a lot of firepower to work with. If they see a player they covet they can move up to get him, or fill the roster out with depth and playmakers the offense has severely lacked the past few years.

Use free agency to round out the team; not to add overpaid “stars”

We have seen this strategy backfire on many teams, dating all the way back to when the Redskins gave Albert Haynseworth a $100 million dollar deal. The Buccaneers currently have $16 million dollars tied up on a cornerback which they gave up a first and third round pick for. While Darrelle Revis is an all world talent, are the Bucs getting an equal return on their investment as a team who is currently 1-8?

While this is a small example, the overall point is that this is not how John Idzik operates. If he is giving up assets such as draft selections, it will be for a highly talented player that is playing on a cheap contract. If the Jets need a middle tier player to plug in a hole, they will go out and sign one but not give up valuable assets to another team.

Dawan Landry, Antwan Barnes, Mike Goodson, and Willie Colon were all excellent high value signings. Landry and Colon have been sturdy along with bringing a veteran presence to a team in desperate need. Barnes and Goodson flashed high impact potential before season ending knee injuries, but will return next season on relatively bargain deals.

In-season signees Josh Cribbs and David Nelson have been near life savers. Cribbs have rejuvenated the special teams while Nelson is the big possession target rookie quarterback Geno Smith has needed. As Kellen Winslow comes back from suspension, he will also look to prove himself as a bargain steal, much like he did earlier in the season.

The finishing touches

The “putting all your eggs in one basket” approach has set back many teams in the past. John Idzik is all about value. Taking Geno Smith with the 39th overall pick, who was the highest rated quarterback on a majority of big boards, is receiving excellent value.

The Jets currently have five players from John Idzik’s first draft as the Jets general manager starting on a team that is 5-4. While some of these player’s impacts have been minimal (Dee Milliner, Tommy Bohanon), others have been vital to the success of the team (Geno Smith, Sheldon Richardson, Brian Winters).

John Idzik has kept a low-profile image throughout his short tenure as the Jets general manager, a much needed characteristic after the Tannenbaum circus era. A quiet architect with a blueprint of a master piece sits in the Jets front office, carefully placing each piece to the puzzle day by day. John Idzik is the man behind this layout, a layout that he will not stray from no matter how loud the surrounding voices become. After all, his surprising foundation and stoic appeal have even silenced the most highly regarded critics in the brightest of lights, the big apple.


Follow Connor Rogers @Real_CR3

  • Big Al

    I agree,, paying big money for free agents in football is way too risky, jets are literally 2 to 3 players away, and that’s not alot, for contending for division next year,, need a WR, and a corner/safety, that’s it,,

  • twoshady

    i wonder if Ed Reed can be had for relatively cheap. might be a quick fix to help the secondary this year.

  • Hillel

    I LOVE Idzik’s style. He’s building a team that can be sustained as a winner over the long term and not taking any short-term big gambles.

  • mike

    good article about a good gm. next year’s draft should be really fun, and the cherry on top will be when idzik extends rex.
    off topic: not a day goes by where i don’t laugh about the bills taking ej manuel with a first round pick.

  • Leo Miranda

    Bohanon has been awesome, way better than Winters.

  • Whitney

    If Geno smith could get good protection and a Pro-Bowl caliber Receiver….Dear God…I see him being at Jay Cutlers Level in a short time. If you watch closely enough you would see that Geno Smith has the same style as Cutler watch some tape.

  • Whitney

    Im expecting Idzik & co. to Go all out on the offensive talent in this draft.

  • Frank Antonelli

    I saw a story on Idzik which I think explains why he is having success. The story goes that he stated that he would rather lose his job and make the right decision instead of saving his job and make the wrong decision. This speaks of integrity and sticking to you plan despite the consequences or noise. When was the last time the Jets had that type of leadership?!

  • KAsh


    I believe you are recalling this article:

    From the decisions he has made so far, I don’t think Idzik likes putting himself into a box. I agree with this article, though I am unsure of what you meant by “round out” the roster. I will assume that it was another way of saying “plug holes.”

    With the draft, you have to realize that most players in the first round will have a rookie year like Coples. This is not a critique of Coples, but just to point out that most rookies, even first-round ones, play situational snaps, are not on the field all the time, or struggle with significant aspects of their game. The Sheldon’s of the draft are rare and there is nothing obvious about them: no top-10 draft pick this year has been a sure-fire starter.

    So, yes, it is better to have a two-step approach to the offseason. Use FA to fill holes, get starters, or sign significant rotation players. Target value in the draft for depth and talent. Targetting needs does not help as much as it seems because you are not guaranteed that the rookie will come out of the gates swinging.

    Short of a collapse in these last seven games, the Jets will have a mid-to-high pick in the first round of the draft. All options should be on the table at that point, perhaps with the exception of the d-line, as I do not see any way that anything but a rotation player can be added there. But other than that, safety, OLB, wideout, tight end, running back, offensive linemen, everyone should be on the table.

  • Nikolas

    A feel good story. But take out Rex Ryan from the equation and this team competes with the Jaguars for Teddy.

  • David

    Idzik has done some good things, but the Jets have had some luck with a few of these players. Let’s be realistic, there were some reasons why David Nelson and Josh Cribbs had not been signed as Free Agents when the Jets picked them up. It is just luckily they have managed to work out so far. Or did anyone think Folk would be perfect for what he is making?

    Say what you will, even with many of the good teams, a little luck goes a long ways. Look at Idzik’s old team Seattle: They have their franchise QB in Russell Wilson and a franchise, shut down CB in Richard Sherman and they are paying them what, 2 million combined? That is stuff you cannot draw up, even with the best GM.

  • kc.

    saying that GINO can/will be on JAY CUTLERS level makes me sick to my stomach.

  • This Jets team is about to be reckoned as a group that you look over a skyline to see if men in red capes are coming; no more circus music will be played because the circus has moved on because we are now, “The Sons of Anarchy”! Giant fans we’ll leave you out of this conversation until you can provide substance enough to merit your name.

    Bottom line; Thanks Mr Idzik for the direction you have us going in and the faith you’ve brought back to the JETS Family, keep up the excellent work and game plan you’ve conceived!!!

    I’ve been in Baltimore over and would love to see my JETS kick the ravens tails. Still working on but if anyone knows someone who can help me wear my JETS gear it would be highly appreciated; i’m just saying.
    But our future is bright and I look forward of telling my tales of old to my Grands, with tales we can share along the way, GO JETS!!!

  • While I’m all for an uplifting story as a long suffering Jet fan, I should remind you that the “most improved” team has two, count’em, wins on last second penalties that resulted in field goals and the subsequent win. So let’s not use the playoff word until certain quarterbacks stop throwing interceptions or make bonehead rookie plays because if Sanchez were making those plays you’d be all over that. We don’t have an RG3 on our hands or a Wilson or “Kapernick” but just some guy who went 39th in the draft. When was the last time a blue chipper was that low and still a premiere player in this league. Caution and results are what win in this league and there are many teams that are as good as the Jets record would indicate.

  • KAsh

    “When was the last time a blue chipper was that low and still a premiere player in this league.”

    Every Jets fan knows the answer to that. We play him twice each year.

  • LawMan

    “We don’t have an RG3 on our hands or a Wilson or “Kapernick” but just some guy who went 39th in the draft. When was the last time a blue chipper was that low and still a premiere player in this league”

    Russell Wilson picked #75
    Colin Kapernick picker #36

    Sorry to point this out but your point actually makes a case how Geno could be just as good in time.

  • Randall

    Excellent article. It’s reassuring to have a GM in place who knows how to plan for the future, without sacrificing short-term success.

  • Fantastic issues altogether, you just gained a new reader. What would you suggest about your post that you simply made some days in the past? Any certain?