Turn On The Jets Roundtable – Overrated New York Jets Edition

The Turn On The Jets Roundtable debates who is the most overrated player on the New York Jets

The Turn On The Jets Roundtable is back to debate issues surrounding the New York Jets. Make sure to give all of the writers a follow on Twitter and if there is a question you want to see us debate, leave it in the comment section! 

Who is currently the most overrated player on the New York Jets?  

Joe Caporoso –  This isn’t the easiest question to answer about the 2013 New York Jets but I’m taking Santonio Holmes over David Harris, who was dreadful last season. At this point, I’m not sure there is any type of renaissance coming for Harris who might just be a slowed-down, run stuffing linebacker in a league that is moving to increasingly spread offenses. Holmes on the other hand has the physical talent necessary to be a competent number one receiver, which is tantalizing when projecting things for the Jets offense but will he ever have the consistency to really be one? People often forget that in seven NFL seasons, Holmes has one 1,000 yard season and only one year with over 55 catches (both in 2009). If he played a full year for the Jets in 2010, he might have two of each but he didn’t. Particularly coming off injury, it’d be foolish to expect true #1 receiver numbers from Holmes. It might be time to look at him as a 1A option on a team with a weak group of receivers. Even an optimistic prediction for Holmes’ stats this year shouldn’t exceed 60 catches for 800-850 yards.

TJ Rosenthal –  Wow that is a tough one. Few Jets who were poised to have good seasons in 2012 completely and visibly plummeted except for the Sanchize. Joe McKnight to our chagrin, never became integrated with the offense but, but overrated? As in others believing he is a force yet who has seen their play resemble that of a mere mortal? McKnight does not fall in that category. Neither does Mark Sanchez. I wanted a lot more out of David Harris last season though. Blame it on injuries or other teams scheming against him if you’d like, but I just have a picture of Harris as someone that fans of other teams fear when they play the Jets. He made a lot fewer impactful plays than I expected him to. I hope that changes in 2013.

Mike Donnelly – This would have been a much easier question to answer last year when there were a ton of options to choose from like Dustin Keller, Brandon Moore, or Shonn Greene. When you look at the roster now though, are there really any players you can say are overrated? I mean, sure players like Santonio Holmes and David Harris are wildly overpaid, but are they really that overrated? Do people really think they are that great to begin with? Tough to say. The one player that it isn’t tough for me to say is overrated right now is one that has not even actually played a single down in the NFL. That man is Geno Smith. The feeling amongst many Jets fans is that just because Geno’s name isn’t “Mark Sanchez” and because he had a good day at rookie minicamp against UDFA’s that he is ready to step in and be an effective NFL starter. That is putting the cart before the horse in my mind because while Geno does have talent and should be groomed and prepared to start, there is just no way to say he is ready to step in on Day 1 and help the Jets win games. Let’s see him play against actual NFL competition and prove he can grasp an NFL playbook that is much different than the offense he ran in college before we start heaping praise on this rookie and expecting big things from him.

Mike Nolan – Although after his injury in 2012, he might not be as overrated now as he once was, the Jets’ most overrated player is Santonio Holmes. I could just be bitter because somehow I end up with this guy every year in fantasy football, and every year he completely disappoints me. Even so, Holmes was given a big contract after an MVP Super Bowl performance in 2008 and a breakout season in 2009. Although he has made some clutch plays in a Jets’ uniform, his body of work leaves a lot to be desired. Since he was traded to the Jets, he has not had more than 52 catches in a season and has a yard per catch average that is on a downward trend as he is no longer the deep threat he was in Pittsburgh. Yet all I hear about is how Holmes is a pure #1 guy when healthy and how he needs to “return to form” in 2013. What form? 50 catches a year? Some might attribute his lack of production to bad quarterback play, but in reality, at this point in his career, Holmes isn’t a true #1 receiver, and I’m not convinced he ever was.

Completely contradicting what I just said, the good news is that if he can stay healthy in 2013, he might have a resurgence in Marty Mornhinweg’s offense as he really hasn’t had a pure #1 option since Terrell Owens in San Francisco. Mornhinweg has had success in the past with receivers that had similar skill sets to Holmes.

Connor RogersCalling a player overrated can be a sensitive topic, but David Harris‘ play last season was definitely underwhelming. To begin, paying a 3-4 inside linebacker $13 million per season is an absolute sin. Even worse, Harris barely put together a mediocre season last year. He’s too slow to cover anyone and got swallowed by blockers against the run at times. For the Jets sake, hopefully playing alongside the declining trio of Bart Scott, Calvin Pace, and Bryan Thomas played a huge part in his worst pro season yet.

Dalbin OsorioIt would be very easy to select Mark Sanchez as the Jets’ most overrated player and just leave it at that. However, people forget just how lights out Moscato Mark played in the 2009 and 2010 playoffs beating Phillip Rivers, Carson Palmer, Peyton Manning, and Tom Brady, so is it possible that Mark is now underrated? Another topic for a different roundtable. The most overrated player on the Jets is David Harris. When you’re paying your middle linebacker top MLB money, you expect top MLB play. He struggled in run support, and seemed to be out of position on every slash or draw ran in his direction. Considering that Harris had 5 sacks and 4 interceptions in 2011 (compared to only 3 sacks and 0 interceptions last year), Jets fans can hope that last season was just a one year aberration.

Cole Patterson – I have this strange feeling that my fellow writers may select MLB David “the Hitman” Harris as their most overrated player, so why buck the trend? This selection is due less to Harris’ actual play than it is to the overall lack of proven players on the Jets. The roster consists mostly of young hopefuls and the talented vets we do praise (Cromartie, Wilkerson, Mangold, etc.) more than deserve it. Harris, two years ago, would easily have been placed in that category. I may have even called him underrated in most league circles. However, the team took note of his talent and payed him top linebacker money, expecting dominant play year in and year out. After 4 pretty dominant years at the MLB spot Harris looked slow and out of place most of last year. He wiffed on tackles and was easily blocked out of plays. Many attribute this decline in production to Bart Scott’s fall from grace but the truth of the matter is, a dominant linebacker should not rely on the play of another to be dominant. Its as simple as that. We hope last year was a drop in the bucket but if Harris continues to require high level of play next to him to reach our expectations, than he is absolutely the most overrated Jet. Addendum: I still dig Harris, believe he is a great person and will continue to sport my #52 jersey until further notice.

Author: Joe Caporoso

Joe Caporoso is the Owner and EIC of Turn On The Jets. His writing has been featured in the New York Times, Huffington Post, MMQB and AdWeek. Caporoso played football his entire life, including four years at Muhlenberg as a wide receiver, where he was arguably the slowest receiver to ever start in school history. He is the VP of Social Media at Whistle Sports

  • Keator

    Nick mangold. Once he got his money his play has declined tremendously

  • __fense

    If someone is mentioned as bad in every single person’s entry, they aren’t overrated, they are just not good. Where are all of the people talking about how great Harris and Holmes are? If anything, Holmes is underrated. Not because he’s that good, but because Jets fans all hate him for no reason.

  • Dima

    “However, people forget just how lights out Moscato Mark played in the 2009 and 2010 playoffs beating Phillip Rivers, Carson Palmer, Peyton Manning, and Tom Brady, so is it possible that Mark is now underrated?”

    I think the very fact that this sentence was contemplated at any point, let alone now, in 2013, shows that there is only one true mantle deserving of the “Overrated” trophy.

    I don’t mean to belittle D.O.; his argument was cogent and well-written, but that sentence is some serious hyperbole. Would you even consider saying that any other player on the Jets’ roster over that stretch “beat” Palmer, Rivers, Manning, and Brady? Including guys on defense (the side that, you know, actually got to face them)? Go ahead, try it.

    See? Can’t get five words in without bursting into laughter.

    Despite how adequately Sanchez played in those individual games and how much public opinion has soured when it comes to his potential, he’s still easily the most overrated player on the roster. Maybe it’s a quarterback thing.

  • KAsh

    It is Holmes, simply because everyone expects him to recover from a Lisfranc injury and return to what he was. Holmes is almost thirty and plays a very demanding position. In a study, 94 percent of all Lisfranc sufferers developed degenerative arthritis in their foot after 2-4 years on average. When Holmes runs, he may not be as fast or as fleet-footed or as confident as before. There might be lasting pain or irritation. He may only play for a few more years. It was a good decision on his part to take some college classes during his rehab.

    And yet people expect him to come back and be the one shining star in the passing game.

  • Jeremiah Johnson

    Mike Donnelly hit one out of the park in this article.

    Overpaid =/= overrated.

  • Robby

    I forgot David Harris played in the MLB but hey I guess anyone can be a writer

  • Dima
  • Lidman

    Keator, Mangold? What he went from being the best Center in the league to only in the top 3? We can argue on how much a Center should be paid, but Mangold has been rock solid for this team, since day 1.

  • Blint

    Its Harris for sure – I have always seen him as overrated.. I actually think he benefited from outstanding play by Bart Scott during the 2009 and 2010 seasons. I can still remember Harris picking off Bradey and getting run down from behind by Alge Crumpler in 2010 – that was absolutely shocking since Harris had a 20 yard lead and Crumpler was not exactly svelte.

  • ronbo

    there’s a saying that your good as the guys you play with and with football its such a team sport bad players can make other players look bad. there are not words to describe how bad the JETS looked last season and I for one want to believe that they are not as bad as they played. Sanchez is not the type of QB that can lift a team but with the right mix he can win and has done so we all want instant success but in real world t hat rarely happens. Only time will tell I want them to be competitive which is not to much to ask especially when you are paying PSAL’s.

  • John C

    In order to be overrated,someone still has to believe your very good. Harris should be ruled out! 3 Years ago I thought he was overrated, now he is just disappointing.